UrbanStudyUrban Research Radar
Transport & Mobility
Journal articleOpen access

Mapping Convergence and Gaps in Fragmented Urban Evidence: A Provenance-Preserving Spatial Synthesis of Ulus Square, Ankara

Published 14 Nov 2026 · Added to radar 18 Nov 2026

Source abstract

Urban public-space research frequently accumulates heterogeneous evidence produced through different methods, spatial extents, temporal frames, and analytical purposes. Although such evidence can often be located within a common geographic framework, spatial co-location does not necessarily imply methodological or evidential comparability. This study develops a provenance-preserving spatial synthesis framework and applies it to the Victory Monument-centred analytical micro-area of Ulus Square, Ankara. Rather than retrospectively homogenising heterogeneous findings, the framework retains the original evidential basis, spatial resolution, temporal status, and methodological lineage of source-supported spatial claims. Evidence was classified as direct empirical, contextual, model-derived configurational, or threshold- or route-based, while contextual observations undertaken in August 2026 were coded separately and excluded from literature-based convergence assessment. Cross-source convergence was evaluated only where spatially and substantively compatible claims were supported through at least two distinguishable evidential lineages. The synthesis identified convergence in pedestrian movement and mobility, commercial embedding, the transport interface, monument-centred spatial context, and temporal differentiation. In contrast, contemporary stationary occupation and duration of stay constituted evidence gaps in the available case literature, while harmonised fine-grained temporal pedestrian flows remained unresolved because the underlying studies did not provide sufficiently comparable temporal protocols, measurement intervals, or variables. The findings demonstrate that a well-studied urban place may remain evidentially incomplete when accumulated studies address different spatial, temporal, and methodological questions. The proposed framework provides a transparent and traceable means of organising heterogeneous urban evidence without erasing provenance, overstating spatial precision, or treating methodological diversity as equivalence.

Abstract metadata supplied by the research index; wording belongs to the original source.

Structured record

Study objective (from source abstract)
This study develops a provenance-preserving spatial synthesis framework and applies it to the Victory Monument-centred analytical micro-area of Ulus Square, Ankara.

Read the original ↗ DOI ↗