UrbanStudyUrban Research Radar
Urban Society & Demography
Journal articleOpen access

Navigating the Chilling Effect: The Impact of Federal Policy Retrenchment on Undocumented Health Care Access in a Sanctuary City

Published 14 Nov 2026 · Added to radar 17 Nov 2026

Source abstract

This study investigates how the intersection of federal, state, and local policies shapes health care access for undocumented immigrants in the San Francisco Bay Area. Through 15 in-depth interviews with health care experts, including physicians and advocacy leaders, conducted between 2024 and 2025, the research captures the impact of recent political shifts. We find that fear, which has long been a barrier to care, has been exacerbated by Trump administration actions, including the rescission of "protected areas" policies and the potential reinstatement of public charge rules. Together, these have had a "chilling effect" on the community. Even in a progressive "Sanctuary City," undocumented patients avoid services due to concerns that enrolling in programs like Medi-Cal will place them on a "list" for immigration authorities. Our research also highlights the continued importance of local safety-net programs. While California expanded Medi-Cal to all undocumented residents in 2024, subsequent 2025 state budget rollbacks and federal Medicaid cuts have introduced new premiums and enrollment freezes. Consequently, local safety-net programs like Healthy San Francisco (HSF) are more trusted and reliable alternatives because they are city-managed and have higher income eligibility thresholds. Regardless, information barriers, language challenges, and provider shortages persist. The study concludes that while local infrastructure provides a vital buffer, the health of undocumented populations remains highly vulnerable to federal retrenchment, requiring durable city-level protections and robust community trust-building.

Abstract metadata supplied by the research index; wording belongs to the original source.

Structured record

Study objective (from source abstract)
This study investigates how the intersection of federal, state, and local policies shapes health care access for undocumented immigrants in the San Francisco Bay Area.
Source-reported findings
  • We find that fear, which has long been a barrier to care, has been exacerbated by Trump administration actions, including the rescission of "protected areas" policies and the potential reinstatement of public charge rules.
Methods
interviews

Read the original ↗ DOI ↗